SEC’s First Enforcement Action on NFTs: A Deep Dive

by | Sep 5, 2023 | Business News, Latest | 0 comments

Image Credit: Photo by Andrey Metelev on Unsplash

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has stepped into the world of non-fungible tokens (NFTs), making its first enforcement action against a company in this space. The company in question is Impact Theory, a Los Angeles-based media company, which has been accused of selling unregistered securities in the form of NFTs. This case has sent ripples across the industry, providing insights into how NFTs could be regulated in the future.

The SEC’s Lawsuit: A Brief Overview

In a landmark move, the SEC is suing an NFT project, marking the first time the authority has taken enforcement action against a company for selling unregistered NFTs. The case revolves around Impact Theory, an LA media company that allegedly encouraged potential investors to view the purchase of their Founder’s Key NFT project as an investment into the business. The SEC order stated that the digital assets offered to investors were deemed “investment contracts” and therefore “securities.”

The Allegations

According to the SEC, Impact Theory “encouraged potential investors to view the purchase of Founder’s Key [the company’s NFT project] as an investment into the business, stating that investors would profit from their purchases if Impact Theory was successful in its efforts.” This, the SEC argues, means that the digital assets offered to investors were in effect “investment contracts” and therefore should be classified as “securities.”

The Settlement

Impact Theory neither admitted nor denied the SEC’s findings but agreed to pay more than $6.1 million in penalties to settle the allegations. The settlement also established a “Fair Fund” to compensate impacted investors. As part of the agreement, Impact Theory was required to destroy all of its Founder’s Key NFTs and eliminate any royalties it might collect from secondary market transactions.

Impact on the Crypto Industry

This case is significant to the crypto industry, which has been hit with a flurry of regulatory clampdowns in the U.S. It offers a clue for how NFTs could be regulated in the future, particularly as many other NFT projects have used language similar to how Impact Theory marketed its digital assets, touting their blockchain-based identifiers as investment opportunities.

Future Implications

Many other NFT projects have used language similar to how Impact Theory marketed its digital assets. These projects have touted their blockchain-based identifiers representing digital asset ownership as investment opportunities. The SEC’s action against Impact Theory could set a precedent for how these projects are regulated in the future.

Impact Theory’s Response

Despite the SEC’s allegations and subsequent settlement, Impact Theory is not giving up on its NFT endeavor. In a post, the founder of Impact Theory stressed that his company will ensure its future digital assets will be for utility rather than financial purposes.

The Founder’s Statement

“We will operate our go-forward business consistent with our good faith best understanding of all applicable laws, rules, and regulations. We will make clear that all of Impact Theory’s digital assets are collectibles with utility within the exciting new landscape of Borderless Entertainment. We will forcefully discourage people from treating our digital assets as anything other than what they are–collectibles with utility. We will have more news on this in the coming weeks and months.”


As the SEC’s first enforcement action against an NFT project, this case is a watershed moment in the crypto industry. It is a stark reminder of the regulatory complexities at play in this space and underscores the need for companies to ensure they are following all relevant laws, rules, and regulations. It remains to be seen how this case will impact the regulation of other NFT projects and the broader crypto industry in the future.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments